I purchased this book as a companion to my Zojorushi Home Bakery Supreme Breadmaker machine. The instructions and the extensive number of expensive ingredients required were initially daunting to me. For instance, the Zo has a preheat cycle, so it's not as crucial to ensure room-temperature liquids. But the recipe book is pretty stringent about that. Which one is right?
Confused, I started out with a Bob's Red Mill bread mix, just to get a feel for the machine. I used cold eggs right out of the fridge, and the loaf from the mix out great. Encouraged, I started trying out the recipes in this book.
One recipes, the Italian Herb Bread, consistently turns out perfectly, even though I use different herbs than those listed. I was able to get the White Bread recipe to work by increasing the flour by 1/4 cup, increasing salt by 1/4 tsp., and decreasing the water by about 1 Tbsp. It also worked when I replace 1/2 c. of the rice flour with sorghum flour. The Basic White Bread (different recipe than White Bread) also came out OK, but wasn't anything to write home about.
Other recipes, such as Multigrain, Henk's Flax, and Ancient Grains, even when followed to the letter, always come out undercooked in the middle, even when I increase the bake time to 70 minutes, which is the maximum bake time for my Zo. Also, these loaves were either very short (never risen) or deflated (rose and then fell). Even tried moving the Zo away from the door to avoid cold drafts - but no change.
One problem is that the Zo (per manual) bakes between 250-290 degrees, and this recipe book assumes that the bread machine will bake at 350 degrees. If I were standing at the machine when the 70 minute bake cycle was finished, I could try initiating another ten or fifteen-minute bake-only cycle and see if that would work. But I bought a breadmaker because usually I don't have time to stay in kitchen and bake bread. I also can't afford to keep wasting several eggs and cups of expensive ingredients while I mess with the recipe - that's why I bought this book. Very frustrating!
I've tried trouble-shooting according to the Zo manual - decreasing/increasing water, yeast, salt, etc. As noted above, this worked for one recipe. But I still haven't found the sweet spot with the multi-grain recipes, which is sad, since I really prefer them over the bland and less nutritious rice bread recipes. Perhaps the problem may be that it's difficult to achieve the desired combination of baking time + temperature using these recipes with the Zo. I am planning to email the authors to see if they have suggestions as to what other adjustments I might be able to make.
UPDATE OCT 13, 2011: After reading reviews, I ordered "Gluten-Free Baking Classics for the Bread Machine," by Analise G. Roberts. This book gives very specific instructions about the best settings for the Zo breadmaker. Although my model isn't exactly the same as hers, the settings worked perfectly with the recipes from the 125 Best book by Washburn and Butt. Those authors did respond to my email (thank you!) after I had already gotten the fix from the other book, but I wanted to recognize them for excellent customer service and a willingness to work on the problem with me.
What was the difference in settings? Roberts recommends a longer preheat than the 125 Best authors (10 minutes instead of none) and selecting Rise #3, which is 20 degrees hotter than Rises 1 or 2.
So, here are the settings I use on the Zo with the recipes from this 125 Best book:
1. Preheat 10 minutes
2. Knead 20 minutes
3. Rise #3 45 minutes
4. Bake 70 minutes
Because of the Preheat Cycle, I was able to use eggs, egg whites, and yeast right out of the fridge. All other ingredients were room temp. I also used the Zo's recommended method of adding the ingredients to the pan, which differs from the 125 Best authors' method.
Using these new settings, two different loaf recipes from the 125 Best book have turned out PERFECTLY! I'm still keeping the rating at 3 stars, however, since the recipes don't work AS WRITTEN for my machine, but are delicious once I learned how to adjust them.
The moral of the story: if you have having trouble making GF bread, don't give up! It can be done!!