Having read and loved Good in Bed, Certain Girls, In Her Shoes and Little Earthquakes, I was looking forward to Best Friends Forever. Having perservered to the end, I am not sure that this was even written by the same author.
The story was so unrealistic as to be farcical the whole way through - a whole police force investigating the crime of a patch of blood and a dropped belt, Jordan breaking into Addie's house since he had "compelling circumstancial evidence", the bizarre praying session between Dan and Meredith almost as if he was being held there against his will, Dan's sudden repentance after 15 years, the ridiculous bank hold up scene with Valerie, Addie just handing over 10,000 dollars for Val to spend after them not seeing each other in years, the two of them going on the run to Florida without actually knowing for sure if they had done anything, honestly, I could go on and on.
I have given 2 stars as I loved the flashback parts, they were beautifully written.
Do not waste your time with this book, Weiner has written great books like the ones I mentioned above, definitely try them instead!