"This is the album that is generally regarded as a classic with Billy at the height of his songwriting powers. You can really see the gutsy New York boxer in him with many of the classics."
"This album confirmed Billy as a worldwide star. This is an enjoyable reminisce of the sounds of his youth from Motown to Frankie Valli but given Billy's fantastic melodies."
"A real rocker, perhaps Billy's attempt at jumping onto the New Wave bandwagon. Not as credible as his previous two (Stranger and 52nd Street), but just as successful."
"Almost all songs on this album have a hit quality with a commercial late 80s rock sound similar to something like Bon Jovi but are still very appealing."
"Billy's last rock album is full of anger which subsides into a sort of contented mood at the end. Yet again Billy produces a good album but not with as many special moments asyou get on previous ones."
"The production lets it down. Otherwise this may have been his breakthrough he was looking for. Nevertheless New York State of Mind is one of his best songs."