I always buy a Bradt guide when I travel, if there is one available for the country. This is because they are much more insightful than the likes of Lonely Planet and will often be scribed from 1st hand local knowledge. Unfortunately, Dr Roberts has really let Bradt's image down on this one.
I've lived in Belarus for the past 2 years and used the 1st edition guide to travel around as well as a source for what to see and do whilst in Minsk. I have now given up on this guide and have oft indulged in a long conversation with other ex-pats here about how Belarus is really lacking an informative guidebook (LP's Russia & Belarus is even worse than this offering).
To start with Minsk, Dr Roberts recommends the bars and restaurants that any visitor would see walking down Nezavistimosti Avenue or in any of the squares. The real gems that are well known amongst anybody that has spent more than a few days in Minsk are notable by their absence. This is a real disappointment and the sad fact is that anybody with this guide is more likely to end up in TGI Friday's for dinner (perhaps the worst TGI Franchise you'll ever come across) rather than in one of Minsk's many excellent and individual bars, cafes or restaurants. Whilst he may have gotten the main tourists sites right, he has missed the multitude of quirky and zany aspects of this city that makes it wholly unique in Europe.
Unfortunately it doesn't get much better as you leave Minsk. Dr Robert's almost totally ignores the impressive city of Mozyr, he glosses over the veritable treat that is the Braslau Lakes and barely gives Grodna, Mogilev and Vitebsk their due. A restaurant that he recommends in Grodna was a standard, awful and unfriendly offering that exists everywhere in the country and locals avoid like the plague. In Vitebsk he avoids points of interest such as Belarus' largest Disco and points the reader towards chain pizza joints. Most shocking perhaps (in the first edition, I've not yet seen the 2nd) was the fact that Dr Roberts failed to note anywhere that the City of Polotsk is claimed to be the geographical centre of europe by the Belarusian government. Whilst more learned geographers would tell you this is just outside of Vilnius in Lithuania, the fact that Polotsk has a memorial to "The Centre of Europe" is a salient fact of the town and I am stunned that Dr Roberts missed. It is a joke amongst anybody who has read this book that Dr Roberts urges people to spent "at least a full day each" at Mir and Njasvizh, both of which anybody would struggle to amuse themselves for more than 3 hours in.
Taken as a whole, I can only assume that Dr Robert's time in Belarus has been spent in a small area and that his tour of the country was whistlestop at best. A very disappointing and underwhelming travel guide is the result. However, still the best on the market. Maybe a real gap exists for the likes of Rough Guide or DK if the market exists. Who knows...