Anyone wanting the complete Beethoven string quartets should look elsewhere as this is not complete. I am not talking about the lack of various snippets that the Endellion Quartet include; I am talking about the lack of Beethoven's replacement finale to the Op. 130 Quartet. The Artemis opt for the Op. 133 Grosse Fugue as the finale, a perfectly sensible course and one that has been followed by many other quartets, but not to include the replacement finale at all is hard to defend in a supposed complete set.
The recordings were made over the period 1998 to 2011 and two members of the quartet have changed in that time. I didn't notice any particular changes in style, indeed one of my favourite discs of the set (Opp. 132 and 135) includes both line-ups. However I expect that their view of some quartets will have matured in that time. Beethoven's greatest quartet, Op. 131, was recorded back in 2002 and I didn't find the reading particularly distinctive.
Clearly the quartet's technical abilities are first rate. They make a more mellow sound than many, with the leader less to the fore than is often the case. I thought that would be good, but I found in practice that they didn't really take me along as I listened. There were many places where the readings struck me as interestingly different, but I wasn't always convinced. I tried alternating my listening with the excellent set from the Tokyo quartet and I consistently found they did a much better job of engaging my attention than did the Artemis.
One remarkable feature is that they fit everything onto seven discs and this hasn't been done by cutting repeats. I think the only one missing is in the finale of Op. 135. The Endellion, the Lindsays (digital set) and the Borodins take the lot. Other top-rated sets, such as the Takacs, Emersons and Tokyo have a few repeats less.
Like the previous reviewer, I tend to prefer IRR to the Gramophone, but on this occasion I don't. This is a perfectly good set apart from the missing finale, but with so many superb sets around it doesn't really merit a place on my shelves.