I'll start with the one aspect of this book which I found positive: it could potentially be a useful tool for a person seeking a mentoring relationship in twleve-step-based recovery. For this reason, I am giving it two stars rather than one. Considering all other facets of the book, I am surprised that it has received so many positive reviews. As other reviewers have pointed out, Beating Ana is one of the first books (maybe the very first) to point out that having a recovery mentor can make success much more likely as an eating disorder sufferer proceeds toward his/her goals for wellness. But I question the assertion that this idea is a new or unique contribution in approaches to eating disorders. For years, sufferers and professionals have applied the twelve-step significance of a sponsor to the eating disorder recovery process. Almost anyone who has been through inpatient treatment for an eating disorder can testify to the fact that recovery is smoother when one is accompanied by others who have been there. This is why support groups can be so helpful. In my opinion, that is quite obvious, and this book presents nothing new or unique on that issue. Another probelm with Beating Ana is that--like many eating disorder self-help books and memoirs--the author seems to presuppose that what worked for her will work for everyone who suffers from an eating disorder. Again and again, this book speaks to the necessity of working the twelve steps, as if there were no other model for mentoring or recovery. For those of us who are critical of the the twelve-step approach for one reason or another...and those of us who have recovered DESPITE the recovery community's inundation with the steps, this book comes across as alienating and limiting. This became even clearer to me when I applied for membership in the online community associated with this book, and I was denied membership because "the community would not be a good fit" for me. I see the potential for many people (particularly those in early recovery) to be misled by this book since it focuses so heavily on personal experience without many qualifying statements. For once, I would like to see a book on eating disorder recovery which does not so arrogantly assume that all sufferers have the same needs or will recover in the same way as the author did. I was hoping to find that in this book when I first purchased it, but unfortunately I did not.
Sarah
*Recovered from an eating disorder