I am a massive fan of The Killers and I do love this album. I've read some reviews that say it's bland and boring and I strongly disagree... I think the album has a lot of variety on it - there's big, epic songs followed by slower, more softer songs. If the songs sounded the same or if they were similar to the previous albums people would complain about that, so credit is deserved for making another unique and different album.
I must admit its not my favourite album of The Killers but its still a great album, and worth a buy. My favourites on the album are Miss Atomic Bomb, Be Still, Flesh and Bone, A Matter of Time and Runaways. Definately worth buying if you're a fan and turn it up loud!