There were three key ingredients in the success of the original "Bat Out of Hell"- the incredible rock operatic voice of Meatloaf himself, the Springsteen meets Lloyd Weber widescreen songs of Jim Steinman-and the incredible production talents (including searing lead guitar and amazing vocal arrangements) of Todd Rundgren.Only one of those is present throughout this CD, and that's what loses the one star.
But make no mistake-this is a powerful and enjoyable album, and probably the best epic rock album of the year.Worth buying? For sure!
First, the good news..Meat sings throughout, and is in superb voice.Whether belting out hard rock machismo,or sobbing tender ballads, his voice is up to the challenge, and sounding better than it has for years.This is a five-star performance on every track, even when singing the nu-metal of "The Monster is loose" or the funky rock of"If it ain't broke, break it!". Vocally, this is a worthy album, and worth it for Meat alone.
The production,while powerful and modern, just falls short of the dynamics and variety of "Bat1". Desmond Child is the man in the chair, and he adds some modern rock flourishes, including some strong songs-"The Monster is Loose" makes Meat a credible modern rock act. However-he ain't no Jim Steinman, and it's clear that his brief here has been to mimic the Steinman style, leading to some contrived piano-based passages and harmonies which are nearly...but not quite!..Steinman.
And that's the one big problem here. There are 7 Steinman songs here, out of 14, and while 7 Steinman songs is better than none..it ain't enough. And if Steinman himself isn't the Steinman of old (Except when it is the Steinman of old as in the superb reworking of "Bad for Good") then one thing's for sure..nobody else is anywhere near as good at this Wagner meets Phil Spector in Springsteen's front room as Steinman himself.
So, what have we got? A great voice, some lovely piano ballads, rock music with real tunes, some guest stars (notably Brian May,doing that trilling Queen lead guitar thing)and a few modern touches.
What are we missing? The subtle dynamics, the magic melodies of Steinman at his best, the sense of theatrics..and a little bit of authenticity. Sometimes it almost feels like Meatloaf creating a tribute album to the real Meatloaf of 1977.
And yet...
And yet...
This is a thrilling great epic Cinemascope rock album, which you will belt out of your car windows as you drive down the highways of your mind , surrounded by ersatz monsters and demons.
And if they're painted by Julie Bell rather than Richard Corben..well it's 2006 not 1977..
Damnit, you'll enjoy it.But it's not really "Bat Out of Hell 3". More like "Bat out of Hell 2 and a half".
Still beats most of the competition, though!