It is very difficult to review, or even describe this book. It is very much like an architectural degree show, in book form, with all that that implies. There is a plethora of ideas tumbling over each other, a complete lack of anything approaching practicality and a frustrating lack of depth to the projects. This is not a criticism of the students whose work is included, but reducing projects to a short paragraph with some illustrations requires the deployment of considerable imagination on the part of the reader. The stalwarts of lumpen collages and over-elaborate CGI fill the pages, while more conventional plans are generally so shrunken as to be illegible.
I suspect that practical architects would find this a frustrating read. Those with a more literary bent, will find much here that is evocative of JG Ballard, Jorge Luis Borges, China Mieville, etc etc. Many of the projects seem to sketch out a setting for some as yet unwritten science fiction.
I do wonder about students putting so much work into such fantastical projects, projects even more speculative than unbuilt Zaha Hadid projects. Creating some parallel universe of unbuildable constructions. Is it a better or worse universe than ours?
Overall I think that if you approach this book in the right frame of mind, then you will find it stimulating and annoying in equal measure. I think that that is a recommendation of sorts. Though I would recommend
Bldgblog Book: Architectural Conjecture, Urban Speculation, Landscape Futures over this.