First impressions were, wow, im going to love this, sadly NOT THE CASE! When you first apply you think it will really work, seems to glide on like a dream, HOWEVER, it soon seems to crack and flake, leaving unsightly patches without coverage! Maybe due to the fact eye shadow peels it off, who knows, but I like to use a little shadow to soften the edges, and this liner does not blend out easily. If you touch up the bald patches, you end up with a lumpy, clogged up effect.
And the other thing, once its been used a couple of times it seems very prone to drying out so it wont glide on at all, and sharpening it is difficult, messy, and wasteful, once used, it will never be the same again :(
This liner is not as smooth as a gel or liquid liner, and not as good as a pencil, its like a cross between, and in this case that idea just does not work :(
It is actually one of the few products I actually considered writing a letter of complaint to Barry M about, just feel its a total waste of money as you'll end up wanting to replace it with another product (like I did)
Two stars, because:
If you dont wear eyeshadow and are willing to keep re-applying every couple of hours (and put up with a little lumpy build up) if I stretch my imagination a little, maybe you will like it?
Waterproof? No you cant wear this to swimming pool, please dont, but I'd say it will stand up to a little light rain;)