There are two major label releases with the Samuel Barber concertos currently on offer: this eclectic collection and the RCA release with Leonard Slatkin and the Saint Louis Symphony accompanying Kyoko Takezawa, Steven Isserlis and John Browning. This compact disc offers advantages in the performances of each of the concertos.
The Stern/Bernstein/New York Philharmonic collaboration is a richly realized performance, fully consonant with Barber's blend of Late Romanticism and modern music. Bernstein encountered the Violin Concerto when it was a work-in-progress at the Curtis Institute of Music, where Bernstein was a student and Barber was on the faculty. (Bernstein's mentor, Fritz Reiner, conducted the early performances of the Concerto at Curtis.) Bernstein was often at his best conducting twentieth-century music; his conducting here perfectly complements Stern's appropriately mercurial performance--now sweet, now steely. There is simply no comparison between this and the Takezawa/Slatkin version: Takezawa/Slatkin is nicely done; Stern/Bernstein is a gripping idiomatic performance.
Yo-Yo Ma and David Zinman give a smashing performance of the Cello Concerto, one of the best things Ma has recorded. Ma nimbly makes the tricky passages of the Concerto sing, while Zinman and the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra expertly frame his work. As good as Stephen Isserlis is on the Slatkin version, Ma handily takes the prize here.
John Browning "owned" the Barber Piano Concerto: it was written for him, he premiered it, and he made it famous with this recording with George Szell and the Cleveland Orchestra. This performance, recorded after a tour with the Cleveland Orchestra, is a fleeter, livelier, more focused account than Browning's remake with Leonard Slatkin and the Saint Louis Symphony some twenty-five years later.
The brightness of the mid-1960s Columbia Records sound in the Violin Concerto and the Piano Concerto has been softened somewhat in this remastering without any loss of clarity. The late-1980s digital sound in the Cello Concerto is on the airy side. You will have to turn up the volume a bit to keep the cello fully present.
Barber was a composer who didn't have much regard for mid-twentieth century trends in music: he continued in his aesthetic path of basically harmonic, often ravishingly beautiful music-making. Because he followed this path, he was out of favor in some circles for long stretches of time. With the abating of some of the passions of certain culture wars, Barber's music has come to be appreciated and enjoyed by a large audience again. This disc is an excellent way to be acquainted with Barber's music, or to savor three of the finest recordings of Barber's music that have ever been done. A basic "can't miss," "must have" selection.
Note to Sony: Why isn't this available in the United States?