I think that for unaccompanied singing to be interesting, there has to be more interest in the melody and more drama in the words. Indeed, there may well be drama in the words but I did not find them distinct enough to appreciate it. I bought this CD for my husband's birthday at his request. He likes it; I find it a headache. There is one song that goes on and on and on with a short repetitive melody repeated in exactly the same way for more verses than I care to count. Tedious, grating, unexpressive. The only variation was a tiny slow down at the end, to let you know it was about to finish. Sigh of relief. Sorry Ewan.