A murder mystery set amongst the literatti of Ann Arbor,this starts off like a Raymond Carver short story and seems like it's going to be something really special before ending like a rather more ordinary Agatha Christie/Ellory Queen type mystery. In between though it's very entertaining for at least three quarters of its length with a long cast of characters, although admittedly, as is usually the case where the plot is the most important aspect,few of them have much depth. It's a cleverly contrived mystery with an unexpected twist in practically every chapter and will have most readers avidly turning the pages.
I don't agree with the comparisons to A Simple Plan, which I thought was a much better book, because stylistically the writing here is quite cool and detached and consequently the central character, David Loogan,never really engaged my sympathies in the way that the characters in A Simple Plan did. Anyway, this struck me as a different kind of book, almost an exercise in classic mystery writing, a book that sets out simply to entertain. It does become somewhat garbled in the last thirty or forty pages with far too much exposition and as with many an entertaining journey the ending comes as something of a minor disappointment.Nevertheless, I enjoyed this and found it a fast and clever read and will certainly be investigating Harry Dolan's next novel.