6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Class of '72, 4 July 2006
This review is from: Back from the Dead: One Woman's Search for the Men Who Walked Off America's Death Row (Hardcover)
Like most Death Penalty Aficionados, I'd heard the name Furman
many times and had wondered what became of him, not to say the
rest of the condemned who were spared due to the US Supreme
Court's historic 1972 decision. Did living in the shadow of the
chair scare them straight when they finally got out of prison?
Therefore, I soon as I heard about this book, I eagerly snapped
it up!
It's a fairly short book and there's a fair bit of
autobiographical detail about the author Joan Cheever, which I
could've lived without (sorry Joan!).
The rest of it is partly about her experiences defending Walter
Williams, his subsequent execution in Texas in 1994 and her
attempts to meet his victim's - Daniel Liepold - mother. All
well and good, but this regrettably leaves little space for the
main course, which is meeting the "Class of '72".
The book deals with only a very few inmates out of the 580+ that
were on the USA's death rows in 1972 and, really, the information
about each is pretty sparse. She does interview the famous
Furman though and finds out what he's doing now. Maybe my
expectations were too much; after all, the "Class of '72" were
largely undereducated, poor and of course, convicted rapists/
murderers etc, so expecting them to be easy to find, willing to
tell their stories in a coherent fashion and for that to make a
gripping book was probably a long shot.
Joan draws some conclusions towards the end and I must say I'm
not entirely sure I agree with them. I don't think you can
equate waiting to be executed with a number of years in prison
with a release date.
If you're fascinated by the Death Penalty, then this book is
probably worth buying. It's certainly readable; however, I'd
have to say that it isn't as good as it could have been and,
overall, is a bit of a missed opportunity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fears and Foibles in Finding Fellows Having Faced a Death Sentence, 8 Sep 2006
This review is from: Back from the Dead: One Woman's Search for the Men Who Walked Off America's Death Row (Hardcover)
Tracking down 589 people is no small undertaking. Ms. Cheever not only does justice to the overwhelming task, but also delves into the depths of the Class of "72, who received a second chance at life after having been sentenced to death. While on her journey to find what became of the "lottery winners" of Furman v. Georgia, Ms. Cheever touches their souls while exposing her own. In the end the author learns the meaning of forgiveness and becomes "the healer" in a justice system wrought with injustice.
The reader learns where and who some of the reprieved convicts are today with the added insight of Ms. Cheever's underpinnings through snipets of her colorful Texas family. Just as the reader comes up for air, having met a former death row inmate and having heard the facts of his crime and punishment, the author teases the reader with a preview of the next unsavory character. At this juncture there is no option to book down the book. There is much to ponder. Kudos to Ms. Cheever whose Notes are as good as the book itself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No