First of all, the basics: the quality of the print material is good, with separate sheets for the cellist and the piano player.
Arrangements are all playable within the 1st position and I could play some of them with less than one year of cello lessons.
However, most of the pieces are far from the level of beauty Bach has accustomed us, hence the 4 stars... excepted the Air in page 11, which is really plenty of emotion. I wish ALL the pieces be in the same level of inspiration.
I recommend it for students wishing to prepare something for the 1st and 2nd year end of year concert.
A good pianist, plenty of patience and good taste, will help for a successful play.