I love books which polarize reader opinions. Let's face it: most stuff these days is either pleasingly good or painfully bad, but rarely memorable. Give me an oddity which can split the public clean down the middle any day! That's why I bought AYUAMARCA, after reading the conflicting views on this very page. It took me a while to get into - I found the prologue very confusing, although it made perfect sense by the end of the book - but after the first few chapters i was hooked. I can see why it's not everyone's cup of tea: O'Shaughnessy attempts that most difficult of tasks, both telling a gripping story and trying to write "literature". There are few of the safe, cliched situations of most fantasy novels: this book assumes readers have a brain and aren't afraid to use it. It doesn't play according to formula, with characters acting the way you might expect or winding up where you may have anticipated. But for those prepared to run with O'Shaughnessy's ideas and free their minds, it should provide lots to think about. The mix of genres is perhaps overly ambitious - I tried to categorize it and simply couldn't; not could i explain to my friends exactly what sort of a book it was: i just told them to buy it and see - but isn't it nice to see a little ambition every now and again? I say give this fresh, forward-thinking book a chance: if O'Shaughnessy's follow ups show improvement (and at 24, he has all the time in the world to fine-shape his act) he could well be one of the best fantasy-based writers of the next ten or twenty years. And i bet his books will still be polarizing readers even then ...