It must be said upfront that this movie is an adaption of the relatively successful short-film "Postmortem", which is featured on
Boys On Film 4 - Protect Me From What I Want [DVD] [2010], and which like the title of the collection is all about protecting people from what they want but really should not have. The short-film in essence seeks to explore what motivates our connections to another person (lover), and how in many instances despite what we know to be best for ourselves, we continue to make selfish and destructive life choices. The film is similar, except for a more substantive exploration of the dynamic between three characters, one of whom seems determined to ignore what is best for him.
Troy is the archetype of selfish desire, who despite being aware of his impact on the lives of others, seems determined to get his own way in all matters that benefit him. Even if this means upsetting the lives of those his loves, the first his ex Jonathan and the second being his brother. Good looking and accomplished he seems to be able to weave and manipulate his way into the lives of those around him, taking a great deal more than he actually gives. His brother who sees through his narcism, at one stage asks Troy what he actually wants in life, to which he receives no real answer. This is what makes Troy's return to California (having worked in Barcelona for several years) all the more painful, as he has no real idea of what he wants, but for a casual longing for his ex. He asks Jonathan to meet with him upon his return, knowing full well the power he has over him. What results is neither unexpected nor unplanned, as Troy seems determined to have his way despite the consequences. Not that Jonathan is innocent in this matter, and his own choices make for some frustrating and annoying viewing. Raul his new boyfriend, who has made the decision to immigrate to the the USA so that he and Jonathan can be together, seems to be a hopeless casualty in Jonathan's misplaced emotions. He is acutely aware of what is happening, but is impotent to do anything about it. Ultimately he forced to make a decision, which ordinarily he would be loathed to do.
The acting is particularly good, with two strong performances from Murray Bartlett (Troy) and Adrian Gonzales (Raul). The supporting cast is also very strong with two very really good performances from Brad Stanley (Devon) and Bernhard Forcher (Sean). Devon is yet another casualty of Troy's hedonism, although like Jonathan seems incapable of extraditing himself from his influence or presence. Sean as his brother is conflicted between his love for Troy, and his personal distaste for the man he has become.
One of my criticisms is that the film is extremely long, and takes far too much time to get to the crux of the matter. Ironic considering that the basic premise is an adaption from a short-film, designed to get its message across rather quickly. Accordingly, the film could have done with better editing, and some carefully constructed direction concentrating more on the dynamic between Raul and Jonathan. It is really these two characters which could have better conveyed the story, with Troy's character being relatively well established early in the film.
It is however, encouraging to see GLBT cinema becoming more concerned with the its story and characters, and avoiding the cheap, stereotypical nonsense endemic in many of the films that have sought to identify and portray this important genre. Although in my opinion French GLBT cinema still excels in this regard, with
One Two Another [DVD] being an excellent example of this theme.