I must admit, the first feedback from other people I had of this game were that it was repetitive and cutesy.
I had played eternal sonata, and the cutesyness of THOSE characters got on my nerves. However, having never played an Altelier title before, I decided to give this one a try - and if it was bad, i would be warned off the series in future.
I cannot compare this game to others of the series as i have not been lucky enough to have played them. So i will base this game on its own merits.
Graphics
The graphics are bright and colorful, maybe not 'up there' in terms of newer PS3 games, but appealing none the less. There are a few story scenes where a static picture of the character is used, similar to visual novel type games. The characters themselves are rather blocky, but this didnt detract from the game
Characters
The characters are all likeable, there are many different characters to recruit for your party, and their special battle moves are really cute! The monsters also look like something Sanrio (hello kitty) would design
Story
The story is very basic, yet charming, and revolves around using materials and ingredients to fulfil townspeople quests to keep the workshop running. Depending on your actions, the story can also delve into the background and pasts of your party members.
Gameplay
The game plays a lot like Rune Factory ( a Harvest Moon type game that incorporates battling monsters as well). Similar to a harvest moon game, the player has 3 years to do various quests for the townsfolk to keep the workshop going. Every action takes time to perform, e.g it may take 2 days to synthesise an accessory. Because of this, time management is essential. It takes time to travel to areas to gather materials. The main character (rorona) levels up in two ways, alchemy/mix levels which determines what items she can create, and her battle level, which is needed when battling monsters in the field.
If this sounds complicated, it really isnt. This game is a lovely way to unwind at the end of the day, and there is something like 14 different endings! You can do quests for townspeople and the characters of your party for special events, and also influences the endings.
There are tons of things to do and places to go in this game, I was never bored for a second, in fact i wished it was longer! :p (although i got a good 25+hrs out of it for one playthrough - and there is a new game + option as well!)
I found the story charming, and it gave me hours of enjoyment, so I rate it a 5 out of 5 :p
If you like harvest moon games, this is definitely for you, or if you are a more casual gamer or just someone that enjoys a fun gameplay, grab it now!