Let me get my cards on the table here nice and early. I've gone from being a regular gamer, to someone who enjoys games when I can find the time. I like games that deliver 'playability', 'repeatability' and 'challenge' and remember when I had an Atari 2600 at home. Buying this seemed like a 'no brainer' purchase way of re-living some of those classic titles, without the outlay (or reliability) worries of buying an old console. Not to mention that the 'portable' factor means that I could sneak in some old school gaming in my lunch break. Having tried this for a week (so far) I'm a little disappointed, to say the least, and can't see this being an attractive offering to anyone other than someone who's trying to tap into those early gaming days.
First up, the information about the 'game' cartridge is a little mixed, with different information as to just how many games are included. You get nine arcade emulations and more than 40 Atari 2600 console emulations. These are right down to the original sound (which is fun for a while, then you'll really want to turn it down to a whisper)
The Nintendo DS is vastly superior in processing power to an old arcade machine and these certainly never going to be any 'glitches' while running these tiny programs. However, the size and resolution of the screen really does hinder the playability and enjoyment of many of these games.
I was really looking forward to playing 'Lunar Lander' and 'Asteroids'. Both games holding a special place in my memory (and taking a chunk of my pocket money), but they're incredibly difficult to play when you can't make out the screens clearly and can't finesse the controls. Deeply disappointing, for me. I can only think that the developers have tested these on their desktops (with nice modern 'large' monitors) and forgotten to check them on the '256 by 192' of the DS screen.
That's not to say that all the games are 'bad'. The integrity of the titles is there, but I can't help thinking that it's failed at the last step, with a few 'rough edges' not polished out. These's niggles that you can't work around and, let's be honest, it undermines the 'enjoyment' value.
I'm almost encouraged to say to people 'wait until hits the bargain bin'. There's certainly going to be a few people trading these back in almost as soon as they've tried it out.