Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Geek and Freak, 6 Oct 2006
This is the second novel I've read in the last several months in which the protagonist is a precociously clever young teenage boy whose main outlet is the secret creation of a comic book/graphic novel. Evan Kuhlman's "Wolf Boy" is an excellent --sometimes painful, sometimes funny -- portrait of a 13-year-old whose big brother has died and whose parents are drifting apart. Here, the titular "Fanboy" is a 15-year-old whose parents are already divorced and has exactly one friend. He's kind of a classic sophomore smart geek loner -- the kind one could well imagine going TCM on everyone if he weren't too smart for that (although he does fantasize about just such a scenario and keeps a list of people he's like to see dead).
Fanboy's into superhero comics and his schoolwork, hates the school jocks (although his one friend is a lacrosse player), and pines for the school beauties. At home, he resents his pregnant mother and tries his best to ignore his "step-fascist", hiding out in his basement room as much as possible, devoting endless hours to his secret project. His fairly miserable balance is upset when a reckless classmate (aka "Goth Girl"), semi-befriends him. This leads to great confusion for him, as he struggles to say the right thing to the ultra-sarcastic, whip-smart, defensive girl, who challenges his notions about how to get through high-school. Lurking in the background to all this is an impending comic book convention where Fanboy plans to show his masterwork to Brian Michael Bendis (a prominent real-life comic creator). This meeting, he assumes, will be the catalyst for his rise to fame as a creative genius and will herald end his current misanthropic lifestyle.
The story is narrated entirely from Fanboy's snide and often whiny perspective, and so I found myself waiting for the other shoe to drop. His dislike of pretty much everyone is so knee-jerk that the reader can't help but assume that at least some of his characterizations are teenage exaggerations and that things are a little more complex than he makes them out to be. So it comes as little surprise that the "step-facist", school jocks, and teen beauty queen all surprise him in various ways over the course of the story. Indeed, it's hard not to come away at the end of the book thinking that if Fanboy was just a little less close minded, he wouldn't be so miserable -- which is perhaps the point. Thus, Fanboy is an exercise in frustration for the adult reader because while he has legitimate issues (like his uprooting to this new neighborhood six years ago and some very real pummeling in gym class), his approach to them is often so immature that one has a hard time sympathizing.
I also had a hard time believing his "lonerness". In a high school of several thousand, it's hard to believe Fanboy wouldn't have fallen in with a few other geeks (and/or freaks) by now. His portrayal of the school is a population of 90% anonymous kids, 9.9% Neanderthal jocks, and himself, plus Goth Girl, who comes out of nowhere. Perhaps the point is that even if those people were there, he is incapable of connecting with them -- however, this seems like a rather exteme stretch given his friendship with the jock comicbook guy. This is a fairly minor quibble however, as the book is nicely paced and fairly entertaining for the most part. It should be noted that those not into comics may find themselves somewhat less interested in Fanboy's "adventures", especially as the genre is at the center of a number of conversations and plot points throughout the book. At a minimum, one should be aware of the difference between superhero and non-superhero (Daniel Clowes, Adrian Tomine, et al) comics genres. Ultimately, it's an effective story about self-esteem that should appeal to teenagers who like to read.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, 1 Nov 2006
Barry Lyga explodes into the teen literature world with his unique debut novel. THE ASTONISHING ADVENTURES OF FANBOY AND GOTH GIRL is a novel about one young man's journey through confidence development.
Fanboy, a sophomore in high school, floats through life hoping to remain invisible since he has, more than once, fallen victim to bullies. His life is a lonely life. His parents have been divorced for six years; his mother is remarried and pregnant, visits with his father are becoming less frequent due to his father's increased social life, and he doesn't relate to his stepfather at all.
Fanboy has been compiling a list for quite some time. The list includes people that have "pissed him off" for no particular reason. Once you are on the list, you never get off. This includes the jock jerks and girls from the cliques that seem to dismiss him as if he has no business even attending school with them.
One bright spot in Fanboy's day is visiting with his friend Cal. Cal is a jock jerk, but also has a passion for comic books, and the two often debate, in depth, about different issues in the comic book universe. The problem with being friends with Cal is, since he is a jock jerk, he doesn't act like much of a friend at school. Fanboy knows to back off when Cal's teammates approach them at school. Most of their conversations take place on the weekends or at night through instant messages.
Fanboy's life begins to change when he receives an instant message from an unknown person. Fearing it is another trick to humiliate him, he doesn't respond. After several messages and an email, he learns that it is a girl from his gym class. Kyra has been witnessing his torment the entire year. She has taken pictures of a bully hitting him in the arm while the teachers do nothing. After this initial contact through instant messaging, they agree to meet and Fanboy's life will never be the same.
The biggest secret in Fanboy's life, which he hasn't even shared with Cal, is the graphic novel he is creating. Schemata takes up all of his free time and he can't stop himself from sharing it with Kyra. She becomes a huge supporter and inspiration for the graphic novel. Fanboy is planning to attend a comic book convention where Michael Bendis himself is going to be signing autographs. Fanboy intends to show Bendis his work and truly believes it will be the break he needs to get Schemata published. Surprising and disastrous events at the convention lead Fanboy to worry about Kyra's well-being. While things don't work out exactly as he plans, Fanboy realizes confidence is the key to his problems. After many uncharacteristic behaviors, he manages to come to terms with some of the issues in his life and makes plans for the future. He even takes
someone off "the list."
THE ASTONISHING ADVENTURES OF FANBOY AND GOTH GIRL will be enjoyed by readers who enjoy teenage problem novels. Comic book fans will enjoy the graphic novel references, especially the cameo appearance by Michael Bendis. While the ending left me slightly unsatisfied, it didn't take away from my overall enjoyment of this novel. This will be a great addition to any collection.
Reviewed by: Karin Perry
|
|
|
|
by Barry Lyga
by Rachel Cohn
by Barry Lyga
by P.C. Cast
