On one level, this DVD set does precisely what it says on the box. It is a five DVD set of the highlights of the 2010/11 Ashes series in Australia which England won 3-1. For that I give it 4 stars. That is precisely what it is, no frills, no extras, 5 tests, 5 DVDs. And for an England cricket fan that is perfectly adequate.
My first minor grumble, and one of the reasons why I can't give it 5 stars is the awful, stupid marketing on the box. It is portrayed as the Greatest Series Ever. The marketing twonk who came up with that one clearly knows nothing whatsoever about cricket. One better than average side played out of its skin to beat an average side playing badly. The greatest series ever that doth not make.
The second grumble is the one eyed commentary. The awful braying, from Mark Taylor in particular, every time an Aussie does something not totally incompetent is almost sickening. The only redeeming feature is listening to the triumphalism when Peter Siddle takes a hat trick on the first day, knowing what is actually going to transpire.
The lack of extras is really what marks this DVD down from 5 stars. In a cricket DVD one does rather expect stats, analysis, reaction. We're cricket fans for goodness sake, we are stattos to a person.
Oh and its a bit of a shame that the commentary doesn't contain the funniest thing ever siad - Shane Warne "You've got to feel sorry for Ricky Ponting".
Still, despite that griping, you can't damage the underlying joy of this too much, so I have to recommend it.