3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb biography of controversial politician, 28 Mar 2007
This review is from: The Arrogance of Power: The Secret World of Richard Nixon (Hardcover)
If the second half of the twentieth century can be described as the 'age of Nixon', then Oxford historian Anthony Summers has written quite possibly the definitive portrait of the decades-defining politician.
If you think you knew Nixon, think again: Summers paints a picture of a venal and deeply corrupt individual, plagued by doubts and self-loathing; yet this Nixon is also absolutely human and capable of political brilliance. This depiction of Richard Millhouse Nixon is no cardboard caricature but a recognisable and conflicted person who could have achieved something exceptional if he had chosen a different path but ended up self-destructing in an inferno of pills, booze, paranoia and subversion, ultimately falling on his sword rather than revealing what he knew about the workings of the secret state, the deep political structure. He was enabled in this function by those who surrounded him and acted as gatekeepers to the king, Bob Haldeman, John Erlichman and Henry Kissinger, people who, rather than attempting to restrain and moderate, indulged Nixon's worst aspects and darker side.
There is an exceptional amount of material that Summers has compiled here but, as with his other books, he writes deftly and never swamps the reader with detail at the expense of narrative clarity. The illegal political maneuvering that Nixon and Kissinger conspired in, to sabotage Lyndon B. Johnson's peace initiative with the South Vietnamese by promising them a better deal once he was elected, thereby undermining LBJ's deal and needlessly prolonging the suffering (on both sides) of the Vietnam war, is meticulously documented, as is just about everything else: Nixon's rise to power, his relationship with John F. Kennedy, J. Edgar Hoover, his relationship with the intelligence apparatus, Texan oil men, the numerous black-bag jobs (possibly hundreds), Watergate being the most infamous, and the Mafia. Ideologues might criticise this book for being a scandalising, sensationalist dirt-digging expose but the facts are plain enough, thoroughly sourced and researched and speak for themselves.
If you relish a good biography or simply want to understand one of the key U.S. politicians of recent decades, then this is the book you need to buy. Once you have finished this, watch Oliver Stone's, "Nixon" - a great film that was made before this book was released (buy the U.S. import and get a much better package: an extended director's cust with roughly 28 minutes extra footage, plus an hour long interview with Stone).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Nixon haters will love this book - but lacks balance, 14 Dec 2000
This review is from: The Arrogance of Power: The Secret World of Richard Nixon (Hardcover)
Summers central thesis appears to be that the downfall of Nixon was in fact simply the culmination of a lifetime of lies, deceit and intrigue. He interprets events throughout his life from this perspective and this is both the fascination of this book and its ultimate weakness.
Summers presents a through and well researched semi-chronological trip through Nixon's life and has uncovered a number of previously unreported incidents - for example the circumstances around Nixon's dramatic return to Washington to indict Hiss was fascinating. The author's style is easy and flows freely. Summers has meticulously cross referenced and noted sources but these do not interrupt the narrative. This book will provide a huge collection of anecdotes and information to support those who already believe that Nixon was in essence fundamentally corrupt.
Where the book and Summers missed an opportunity was in bringing to his research and thought an element of objectivity that would have added weight to his central argument. The constant and unrelenting analysis of every event in the most negative way calls into question the arrogance of the author rather than Nixon. Those who are prepared to give Nixon the benefit of at least some doubt may find the constant carping annoying.
Essentially you will either love or hate this book, but that will depend on your existing views of Nixon.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A poorly written hatchet job., 6 Mar 2007
This book is tabloid-style gossip dressed up as political biography. Most of the 'revelations' have been seen before. Also, Summers appears unable (or unwilling) to give Nixon credit for anything. This is as bad as Seymour Hersh's book on Kennedy.
Anyone wanting single-volume works on Nixon should buy the books by Richard Reeves and/or Melvin Small, both of which are excellent.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No