If you read only one selection of poetry this year, make it this one. The idea - living poets choosing and responding to poems from the past - is simple enough. But it works really well, and the result is a fascinating diversity of responses. There's straightforward homage (Gillian Clarke's `Nettles', taking its inspiration from Edward Thomas' `Tall Nettles'). Sardonic riposte (Carol Rumens' warm and optimistic countering of Philip Larkin's misanthropic `This Be The Verse'). And moving elegy (Owen Sheers' `Elegy: To her Husband Going to Bed', in which John Donne's wife gives voice to her child-bearing fears, and past grief, in counterpoint to his confidence, as expressed in Donne's `Elegie: to his Mistress Going to Bed'). Throughout, the new sets off the old, shedding light on it from sometimes startling angles. Occasionally, the contrast with the new is unflattering: U.A. Fanthorpe's `A Word, Camerade' (a plea for agnosticism about the nature of animals' communion with God) exposes the narrow-minded, self-satisfied presumption of Walt Whitman's `The Beasts'. Editor Carol Ann Duffy's own contribution, `Kipling', is a brilliant exposé of the banality behind the bombast in Kipling's ghastly poem `If'. Pretty well all the `answers' in this collection work - and in such a variety of ways, at so many levels, that this little volume will absorb and delight even on the umpteenth reading.