On reading 'My War Gone by, I Miss it so...' I was left with a complete sense of awe. I felt that I had read something completely new that had expanded my worldly view and provoked thoughts and ideas that I had never considered before. It inspired me to go out and read more war correspondence, initially Michael Herr's 'Dispatches', before returning to this, Loyd's second book. Unfortunatly, I came away feeling that I'd been somewhat cheated.
There is no doubt that this book contains interesting accounts of Loyd's journalistic escapades and brushes with death, however the vast majority of the book feels like edited out pieces of his first book. If you were to read both book simultaneously you would struggle to identify from which book which story came because, apart from a few additions, both books recall tales from the same periods, places, personal struggles, family relationships and many other things. The only real addition to 'Another Bloody Love Letter' other than some more up-to-date war correspondence, is a regular recollection of shared events with Loyd's fellow journalist Kurt, to whom this book generally serves a memorial to.
Yet, on saying that the two books are very similarly matched, I do feel that the writing in this book is somewhat more forced. In 'My War gone by...' I genuinely connected with the fear that being on a front line being overrun by an enemy was like, understood Loyd's shock at some of the sights he witnessed. However, in this account, the strongest sentiment that I felt was an undercurrent of angst and despair at losing a friend as opposed to the war correspondence. While I have no intention of detracting from the significance of such a loss, 'Another Bloody Love Letter' is more of a dedication to Kurt using the edited out pieces of 'My War gone by' as a vessel to do so.
While this book is a very good read, for those who have read 'My War Gone by...' first it will seem all too familiar. Perhaps the general perception will be that whichever you have read first will have greatest impact, and for me having read this second it seems that I will fall into the category that places this as the inferior.