Nicola Upson's first crime novel featuring Josephine Tey was set in London, packed with period detail of Theatreland and with an unusual but intriguing plot. Sadly this second novel fails to live up to the promise of the first. Upson sticks with her detective, Archie Penrose and with Josephine Tey but moves the location to Cornwall. The plot has its dramatic moments but frankly gets sillier and sillier. Although, according to the blurb, Upson lives for part of the year in Cornwall, she is far less confident in conveying a sense of place this time round, the dialogue is lumpen and, as another reviewer has commented, this could be set in modern times. It fails to create any sense of period. I turned instead to the real Josephine Tey and read 'Miss Pym Disposes'. What a revelation. Beautifully written and understated and a carefully revealed denoument which had the power of surprise. If you are keen to read period crime, try Tey herself.