The very fact that this book seems to have stirred up a nest of controversy speaks well of Brent Nosworthy's pioneering efforts in analyzing the "brass tacks" of 18th century military tactics. This is an exhaustive study of how the various national armies of the period deployed and fought in line of battle. Many of those elements normally associated with Napoleonic warfare had their genesis in the period from 1688 to 1793 including the effective use of skirmishers, columns of attack, and infantry squares.
Brent Nosworthy does a brilliant job of analyzing the similarities as well as differences between the tactics and drill regulations used by the great powers of Europe with special attention placed on the French, English, Austrian, and Prussian developments. From the introduction of cadenced marching (appearing very early in the Prussian system and much later in that of the French) to the various methods used to deploy from column into line and back, the details and problems confronting the armies of the time are discussed in great detail.
A series of diagrams at the end of the book complement the richly detailed text enabling the reader to gain new insights into the nuances of the 18th century firing line. For anyone who wishes to know why the Prussians under Frederick the Great marched so well or why the English volley was so effective, this book is a "must-read." Brent Nosworthy should be complemented for his thoroughness in using a mass of primary resources to produce such a useful work for the military historian, wargamer, and historical re-enactor alike! -James J. Mitchell