I started reading this in April '09 - partly to see whether there were lessons in understanding the 2009 crash, and partly to see if there were any hints about foreseeing the start of the climb back out. And I liked his approach - give quotations from the Wall Street Journal in the days running up to the turn and shortly after, and try to see what it was that changed people from pessimists to optimists and got the markets moving up.
The author is very picky about what he considers a bear market - and ends up analysing just four - 1921, 1932, 1949 and 1982. He then decides that the Wall Street Crash of 1929 (or 1932 - which was the bottom of the market) was so unusual that we can't draw lessons from it.
So suddenly we are only looking at three events, and trying to draw generalisations from them. I got sceptical.
But at the same time I was reading the book, the maket was showing some (clearly false) signs of life again. And the signs that the author mentioned (drops in interest rates, increases in copper prices, ...)were also appearing. Just a coincidencce, since the market was so obviously set for further falls.
Needless to say, the small investments I made at the time (just in case the author was correct - a bit of regret minimisation by me) have seriously outperformed the rest of my portfolio.
It is an interesting book - readable, educational and well researched. And I think the author will find he has another chapter to write on the 2009 bear market that fits in quite nicely with his thesis.
If only I had believed him the first time!