This is a fine novel, all in all, well crafted and full of suspense. Though categorised as juvenile fiction, An Angel for May is most certainly not only for the kids. This adult found it to be quite riveting indeed. And yet, just as the book has captured one's imagination for the grand finale, it is let down by its weak, confusing, and unconvincing final chapter. The conclusion is muddy -- written too hurriedly, perhaps? -- and left me with a sense of wanting far more after the sustained drama of its first 140 pages. Very disappointing.
This is one of those rare instances where a film version, sensitively directed by Harley Cokeliss and nominated for an International Emmy, actually improves upon the literary original. By all means, seek out the wonderful film of An Angel for May, now available on DVD and beautifully handled from beginning to end. The conclusion of the film is MUCH more satisfying than what Melvin Burgess delivered with the written word, causing me to wonder if screenwriter Peter Milligan consulted the author beforehand.
Enjoy the book, but love the movie.