Mr Galvin's subject deserves attention, and in Scotland at this time perhaps more so than in the USA. He is therefore to be congratulated for identifying a subject worthy of a book in a time when many subjects are not.
However, having read this book, I felt cheated. In small format and having 82 pages, the text is large and interspersed with illustrations and blank pages which reduce the actual number of pages with text by 16. So you get little for your money. But there is worse: The large point size used is at odds with the small format and means that any logical layout inherent in the text is obscured. Regrettably, I must also take issue with Mr Galvin's style. Perhaps this is a cultural problem, but it seems to a modern day Scot reading this book that Mr Galvin has deemed it appropriate to convey his thinking about a subject of the intellect with what appears to be intended as high-flown intellectual prose. What he achieves is confusion and obscurantism. The text of this book originates from extemporary speeches by Mr Galvin; it seems that Mr Galvin and his editor have not taken sufficient trouble to translate such verbal utterances into a worthy form of prose.
A great admirer of the American Founding Fathers, and in particular Jefferson, an astonishing Renaissance Man of the Enlightenment, my hopes for this book were for inspiration for the Scotland of today, suffering from superficiality, envy, parochiality and political mediocrity. Experience demolished those hopes!
I live within 50 yards of a tall obelisk, a monument to George Buchanan, of whom little is known in our community and of whom mention is made by Mr Galvin. At least the unsatisfying incompleteness of Mr Galvin's treatment of George Buchanan's contributions prompts me now to find out more!