After
Good Omens and
Anansi Boys this is my third excursion with Neil Gaiman and unlike with the first two, which I enjoyed a great deal, this one was a bit of a mixed bag for me.
The book is based on a fabulous premise - namely of people bringing gods they worship / associated ideas into the new land they move to - in this case America. That these then need to arrange themselves there, in competition with many other views and in a land, which according to the author is not 'very suitable' for gods is in essence what the book is about. This story then unfolds in the book through the experiences of Shadow - the ex-con protagonist - who gets throuwn into this aspect of life after leaving prison. As such, the basic idea, the cultural commentary and the overall plan being set are great, with execution leaving, on occassion, a bit to be desired.
First of all, the length. While I almost always have a preference for a book longer rather than shorter, I did on several occassions (especially towards the middle) get the impression that this one started to drag a bit. This is the author's prefered version of the text - meaning that ca. 12.000 words that have been parsed from the first edition by the editor got reinstated in some shape or form. Not having read the earlier version, I cannot say for sure but my impression is certainly that the book could easily skip that amount and gain, rather than lose somethingn (just like it is interesting for fans to see
Apocalypse Now Redux [DVD] [1979] to fill in some details in spite of the plain vanilla
Apocalypse Now [1979] [DVD] probably being much better rounded as a movie).
On top of that, one gets the impression that the author often chose to forego focus to benefit inclusion - i.e. a lot of the vignettes included read more as testaments of research done, rather than a part of the story (granted, this may well be seen as a feature by some and certain ones of the vignettes present some of the best writing in the book).
Shadow, as a character, is perhaps not particularly memorable or someone you would naturally identify with, an aspect that may also turn some of the readers off. Whether he is believable is hard to say - people handle extreme situations in mysterious ways and one can certainly believe that his is a possibility.
In spite of these criticisms, I still find the book worth reading and apart from some 40 or so pages in the middle, I did not find it difficult to do so - conversely, at no point was it a page turner for me, either. If you can forgive the author his enthusiasm getting the better of him (and thereby bypassing some of the regular editing process) and are willing to follow the idea, and if the size does not deter you, I find the book to certainly provide adequate food for thought and enjoyment, even if it is not the author's best in my opinion.