I became tired of the gung-ho macho bs surrounding the majority of the arms of the illustrious American War Machine and its capabilities. Thats why this particular book is so crystal clear on the humanitarian side of combat. Its not all 'we can do this cos we are the best' as you usually encounter with most American Forces personnel. It actually tells a very descriptive story of what the British Army colourfully term a 'clusterf**k'. The best laid plans always go to pieces as soon as the first rounds go downrange. Task Force Tarawa's (TFT) plans were no different. Ambush Alley highlights the divide between narrow minded elitist higher ranks, the knock on effect of which brings unnecessary and unhealthy rivalry,friction and disregard of other rank's indepth experience within their chosen field and in the long run the problems that come from it. Sometimes the US Marine Corps aren't all they brag about. No communication between Army elements and TFT led to 507th Maintenance Company getting hammered, yet no-one knew about it. TFT then unknowingly stumbled into the kill zone. Extremely poor radio discipline from the Marines' own elements causes communications problems. That then in turn caused the battleplan to fall apart straight away. The rifle companies ended up spread out in different locations to what they had rehearsed, they couldn't contact each other as comms was impossible and the poor young Marines at the sharp end started taking casualties from a very dominate Iraqi force from an area the Marines' own Intelligence said wouldn't put up a fight. The area was in fact so hostile, even women and children were at the forefront of the urban battle. Then as if that wasn't bad enough, poor organisation and comms again led to the Marines' own Forward Air Controller clearing two US Air Force A-10 Warthog Tankbusters for gun runs against their own guys, claiming 75% of their inflicted casualties. The victims of this US military debacle is as always the young scared grunts on the ground.
Ambush Alley is a truly excellent read - very well written, fast paced, expertly detailed and most of all honest to the guys who experienced/suffered the failings of their own moronic chest beating higher ranks and ended up paying for their incompetence with a lot of unnecessary blood. This is the true description of war and what happens when its dogs are released. Very insightful although at times harrowing, if you enjoyed Black Hawk Down, this should be in your book case