The jacket blurb claims that in this book Jane Smiley gives us a 20th century view of life in the 19th century American midwest. At the beginning, I felt overwhelmed by the the 20th century gloss. Naturally we admire a carefree tomboy who can swim the Mississippi in her shift, but isn't that just because we wish that a woman could have been like that then, and still have thrived? As the book progresses, Lidie Newton sheds her skin many times, adapting to every new circumstance with self-preservation, but leaves herself and us wondering who she really is. By the end, I greatly admired Jane Smiley's vision. In Lidie Newton she has created a heroine who just as heroic as the rest of us, and not one bit more. At one moment she is supremely confident of the right action and the next wonders how she could have ever thought herself capable or been so confident. When we look back on the 19th century, we see divisions between men and women, between races, between slave and free, and we confidently see the path to equality for all. But how would we have felt if we'd really lived though it? Jane Smiley has thought that one through, and given us Lidie Newton as an answer.