Whilst many reviews have lauded the quality of the book, it's presentation and clearly fan driven narrative of it's author Ian Nathan who has managed to collate successfully data from numerous sources including older books, blu-ray commentaries and EMPIRE interviews, this review concentrates on the imagery, namely the photographs contained in the book should someone be hoping this is also a DEFINITIVE reference for ALIEN.
Many of the images of production photos and concept art have been seen before are seen in colour for the first time here. And whilst the concept drawings of Chris Foss, Moebius and Ron Cobb, the paintings of HR Giger have reproduced clearly (if somewhat darkly) the same cannot be said of the majority of behind the scenes stills which fall below expectations.
The presentation of the book is excellent as has been previously noted, but the formatting sometimes leaves a lot of dead white page around smaller stills that could have been made larger and to bleed off the page, especially at the top and bottom of pages (when this is done in the book it works much better, image-wise). Whilst colourful on the good quality paper, the majority of photos suffer from poor reproduction; soft looking, blown out highlights, dense large areas of black shadow with no detail. This is frustrating when compared with the same images in other books or on the internet that are sharper with more shadow detail (and really unforgivable in an age of digital scanning and clean up) . This is especially true of the Nostromo model ship which the book fails to have one decent picture of! Disappointing given the wealth of imagery on the internet especially with the recent restoration of the model. Even the adult alien was better catered for in previous publications. I would have preferred many more large, rare and detailed images to be able to refer to, but maybe that's a different book.
Where the book does score better though is in the reproduction of some concept art and rare Ridleygrams, Director Ridley Scott's own storyboards that provide additional insight into the movie making process . I could have done without the "Enclosures" gimmick (which makes flicking through the book difficult); loose images of FOLDED posters and notes that would have been better served being given a full page in the book (or a bigger book). But the Nostromo blueprints are a nice geeky treat! These are NOT floor plans of the stage sets as with the STAR WARS blueprints; this is front, side and top of the model) I certainly wouldn't buy this book second-hand given these additions would be likely missing!
There are interesting behind the scenes shots to be had in this book, but there still remains to be seen a definitive comprehensive image reference book on the sets, model work and concept art (other than Giger's work which has been covered extensively) that is given the same respect and reproduction quality (such as the Art of STAR WARS books) that fans of ALIEN would love to own. Hopefully this is lying in another vault waiting to be discovered!
The enclosure bonus's aside, the imagery is for the most part functional, to support the text. This is a book for the definitive story of ALIEN rather than the definitive imagery of the film but since it fulfills that admirably with passion from an obvious fan in Ian Nathan I will still give this excellent value and well presented book 4 stars for being ALMOST perfect.