Francine Prose does a good job of getting under the skin of the tribe of teenagers attending Central High, in this promising scenario of paranoia and the scary tactics employed following a shooting at another nearby school, ironically named `Pleasant Valley'. Mr Willner is a professor of clinical psychology drafted in to provide the Central School community with trained, professional guidance. It helps, at first, that he looks a little like Abraham Lincoln and has an unnerving quality that lends him authority. The current headtacher, Mr Trent, is gradually elbowed aside and soon, the only person anyone is allowed to listen to is Mr Willner.
The book focuses on a small group of kids who are intelligent, but also like sports. "We were known as rebels. Sort of. Because there wasn't much to rebel against, we never got into actual trouble." Silas smokes pot on a weekend, but his friends watch out for him, Brian is way too handsome for his own good, and Avery is one of the very few black kids in school who mixes with the white ones. The narrator is Thomas who lives with his Dad and his Dad's girlfriend Clara. His Mom died four years ago in an autowreck. He's not keen on Clara, but she's becoming slowly more acceptable - though he's sure she could never take his mother's place.
Over the next few months the mood of the whole town is going to be infected by the way Mr Willner intrudes into relationships between the pupils, and between the pupils and their parents. So much so that it seems to the rebel kids (who aren't really rebels), that their school is slowly turning into a prison. When does counselling become bullying? When does a shortened book-list become censorship, and will the Central High pupils give in and inform on each other as Mr Willner wants? The kids joke about an Invasion of the Body Snatchers scenario, but how far is Mr Willner prepared to go?
The ending uneasily straddles a theme taken to its conclusion and something slipping into fantasy. But in the Land of the Free, with the right to arms, the Tea Party and Fox TV News, who knows how likely it might become?