There is nothing to dislike about these boots! Sizing was perfect, I am women's size 9, they are just right with thick socks, or would be ok in summer with thin, a bit like Wellington boots. They aren't sloppy, but are big enough to get your foot and jeans tucked into. I was worried there is no side zip and getting boots on in the first place would be an issue, but, they have got it all right and I have no prob.Nice and high around the leg. Good sole, have been out in all weathers walking the dogs, mud rain, slush, all good. So stylish too. Have gone from Dunlop to muddies and many boots Inbetween and these are by far the best. The leather tongue on top was a bit uncomfortable for the first couple of walks, but thick socks solved that and now they are comfortable and flexible. Deserves the 5 stars.