Over thirty years after it's original release, this album stands as the Boomtown Rats finest hour, and with the addition of two of the best B-sides ever, the CD edition improves on the original vinyl. A Tonic for the Troops finds the Boomtown Rats at the peak of their musical development. It was a marked development from the first album with highly original songs and a departure from their Dublin roots, except Normal People and Rat Trap. It had a very definite sound which is a criticism that could be levelled at the albums that followed. The backing vocals were harmonious, Gerry Cott's guitar solos to the forefront, and Geldof's lyrics had not started veer into the mawkish sentimentality that he could be guilty of.
The album showed The Boomtown Rats to be a more accomplished band than almost all of their peers in terms of song writing and musicianship. Tonic for the Troops stands as The Boomtown Rats finest moment for the inventiveness and excitement in the songs. Most importantly this album captured the zeitgeist, being around at the right time and effectively defining the sound of 1978 as much as Parallel Lines, Give `em Enough Rope and Never Mind the Bollocks all of which it shared the record racks for the whole year.
There are very few albums where every track can be considered excellent, but this is one. The Boomtown Rats went on to make many good songs but arguably never made another great album which not only fitted the times but was timeless.
The bonus tracks do add to it. D.U.N. L.O.A.G.H.A.I.R.E. and Do The Rat are B-side masterpieces. Genius.. D.U.N. L.O.A.G.H.A.I.R.E was based on a song called Cocaine In My Brain Geldof took the "A knife, a fork, a bottle and a cork. That's the way we spell New York" refrain and applied it to his home town to hillarious effect. Garry Robberts attempts at spelling Dun Loaghaire are dismissed, and corrects him with "Drab and dreary, Tired and Weary, That's the way you spell Dun Loaghaire". Reminiscent of Derek & Clive, (or possibly Zig & Zag at points, eventually the world gets to spell and sing Dun Loaghaire. All done to a wonderful calypso beat. It was released as a cover flexi in the UK, but also as a b-side to Clockwork on Mulligan records (The Rats Irish label).
Aping The Twist, and other dance craze songs, the Rats create their own, The Rat! With yellowed teeth and greyer hair, I'm less up for doing the Rat to the break of day these days, and it's pretty fair to say The Rat didn't really supplant seventies disco! The song itself is a very basic three chord (if that!) romp, but the lyrics are very sassy and the R'n'B guitar break sounds like it comes from Tiger Feet by Mud! On the CD it ends with a Beatlesque cheer a la All You Need is Love.
The stripped down less polished Neon Heart is of most interest to completists rounding out the Peel session released on Geldof's Crazy single.
Rat Trap (Live In Stoke) sounds like it came from the Rats post 1980 as the horns are more to the fore and the guitars a little subdued.
Personally, I think it is certainly the greatest album of the 1970s and one of the greatest albums of all time!