I read this book after reading Yiyun Li's wonderful novel "The Vagrants" which really impressed me. However, I found this collection to be of variable quality. Some stories touched me but others left no impact. Although the stories have the author's hallmarks of showing how people are emotionally connected no matter how much they suppress their emotions and no matter what the political vagaries, they are not much more than vignettes of people's lives, there is no particular theme or themes to this book. Yiyun Li's talent is her sharp eye that is able to observe deep inside her characters to unravel their thoughts and motivations. But the stories are not connected enough to give us a broader picture of China (or Chinese immigrants), and they do not have the universality of her novel "The Vagrants". I see these stories as early attempts at her craft, practicing for a much the much bigger canvas of "The Vagrants" which she wrote after this.