For the genuine melomane, that is the music lover whose interest spans the totality of the great European tradition, there comes a time when one realises that there is just too much of it to do it all justice in a single lifetime. All the same, one tries to build a picture of how the various styles, forms and genres evolved, of who influenced who, and who provided the foundations for a later composer's innovations, and so on. To do this, we tend to build a cumulative historical picture from the sleeve notes of the discs we purchase, supplemented perhaps by a biography or two. Eventually however, we become aware that our picture is filled with gaping holes and the odd contradiction, formed as it is from information on the music and the figures with which we are familiar, but not from those with which we are as yet unfamiliar. For an integrated picture one must resort to a history of the subject, to which there are two approaches. The slow hard road is exemplified by Taruskin,
Oxford History of Western Music: (5 Vol set), with its huge wealth of detail and large number of supporting examples. I am slowly chomping my way through this woolly mammoth of a set, but after some months I am still in the 15th Century, and to be honest the detail is a little overwhelming. The second approach is through something a little more brief and concise, of which this has proved to be an excellent example. It has only taken me a few days to read but I find I have come away from it with a subtly shifted perspective on those many hallowed names of composers, musicians and the thinkers and writers who informed them. As I write this review I am casting my eye over the spines of my CD collection, organised from Adams to Zimmerman, and I find I have a renewed and deepened sense of what they all mean as a whole. Surely then this extremely lively and entertaining little book has accomplished the goal for which I purchased it. Any history can only ever be a story, as the word itself would imply. A story that we have constructed of how the past looks to us from where we are now, with the materials that are left to us. There are many ways the story can be told, and the variations increase with the more we must choose to leave out, as a concise history must. Nonetheless I have found this to be a particularly engaging account, and one that does not jar with what I thought I already knew of the subject, bringing clarity to those areas that were vague. I will be pressing on with Taruskin, but I already feel myself to be on far firmer ground having absorbed the contents of this, its leaner cousin. In fact, I have every expectation of reading this little book again at least once more, to better absorb its lessons, and to reinforce the foundations on which more detailed books can build.