First Sentence: Emily Radley stood in the center of her magnificent drawing room and considered where she should have the Christmas tree placed so that it would show to the best advantage.
Charlotte Pitt has bronchitis, her mother is traveling so Thomas Pitt requests that Charlotte's sister, Emily, answer the request to travel to a small town in Western Ireland where her aunt, who had broken from the family by marrying a Catholic, is dying. Rather reluctantly, Emily complies.
During a severe storm, Emily sees a ship in distress upon the coast. The one survivor reminds the town of a similar incident several ago, resulting in an unsolved murder. Trust of each other has never returned to the town and can't until Emily uncovers the killer.
Ms. Perry's skill at description and creating a strong sense of place was very much in evidence as well as was the emotional questioning and growth of Emily. The characters were interesting--Perry is wonderful in the creation of her characters--but they seemed a bit flat. The mystery wasn't compelling. The story didn't have the emotional uplift others have had and felt somewhat unresolved.
As much as I love Ms. Perry's Christmas books, I felt this was the weakest thus far.