I completely agree with L.B. Guernsey. I recall the first Nebula I picked up years ago and it contained only the great sci-fi stories with, perhaps, a few commentaries. I am wholly disappointed with this year's Nebula book. Why are there not more stories? At the end of the day, the reader will decide which story is the best, regardless of how the committee selected their winners. So, give them to us! Another thing...we live in the age of information. I can travel through space and time with search engines and come across volumes of information regarding sci-fi, how it is written, what were the influences, who were the authors, etc. Please do not make this book turn into a useless compendium of critics notes on what sci-fi is. That is what other books are for. At the end of the day, I hope future editions of the Nebula books capture the stories and authors, as they would have liked, rather than serve as a platform to define the term "science fiction".