Essential purchase or pointless money-making tie-in? Gladly I'm happy to report this is leaning towards the former, though whether it can justify being a full-price release (an RRP of £29.99 would have been all the more appealing) is another question. Hopefully I can help answer that with this review.
First and foremost, this definately is not a game just released to capitalise on World Cup Fever - while players of FIFA10 will be hard pressed to see too many differences in gameplay, FIFA 2010 World Cup certainly offers up a unique experience and is arguably the most successful football game of this console generation. The gameplay differences are subtle, but the tweaks are there and largely they are impressive.
As this is a World Cup game, the first point to note is that there are obviously no Liverpools, Norwich Citys, St Paulis or Cruz Azuls. What there is though is impressive - all 199 nations who took part in qualifying, from the might of England (ha!) to the minnows of the Seychelles. Not all teams have official kits etc, but a large amount do, and it's impressive how ITV commentary duo Clive Tyldsley and Andy Townsend mention the names of even the most obscure Vanuatan player. Talking of commentary, this is a nice touch, using terrestrial commentators instead of the usual Andy Gray and Martin Tyler as of course the World Cup will be screened on normal television. It's in the liscensing details FIFA excells over PES (well, a few other areas too), and the use of official World Cup score bars and captions only adds to the autenticity created.
As mentioned, not all kits are official though and those that are suffer from similar issues found in FIFA10. I appreciate the work that goes into a game is immense (and game line producer Simon Humber recently explained that they are sent kit designs months in advance and it's not their fault when manufacturers change designs last minute). However, the kits don't look as good as PES and frankly there's no excuse for the incorrect Cameroon kit from FIFA10 to still be in this game (look it up online and compare it on FIFA - how could they get it wrong again?!). However major graphical improvements aplenty concerning player faces and the pitch itself, players look the best they've ever looked in a FIFA (still not quite as good as PES 2010 though) and the pitches finally look like pitches, rather than luminous green swamps (okay, they aren't THAT bad in FIFA10, but they weren't that good). All world cup stadiums are present and correct, as well as major stadiums from the major nations. You also have broadcast cut-scenes in game, some of which feature the managers, largely superflous but it's nice to see Cappello on the sidelines, mouthing orders and waving his arms. Another nice addition is, in World Cup games, there will be lots of confetti along the sides of the pitches, giving that canrnival feel...
...which leads me onto the audio used in the game, which is excellent. Aside from pretty decent commentary, the crowd effects are fantastic, a wall of noise with team specific chants and drums (for example, when playing with England not only do you get chants of 'God Save The Queen' etc, but you also get the (I presume Sheffield Wednesday) band playing Rule Britannia'). There's a real buzz present in World Cup games.
Gameplay-wise there are a few tweaks, but nothing major - if you are thinking of purchasing this game it shouldn't be because you're expecting a radical reworking of FIFA10 because you won't get it. However, there are some new animations, players seem to react to opportunities a little quicker and the game pace is slightly quicker, even on slow. Shooting is a touch better, but still can be floaty compared to the delights of smacking a ball with Gerrard in PES, though crossing seems better to me at least, I've certainly had more success from corners in FIFA2010WC than in FIFA10. Celebrations are tweaked so after scoring it zooms in on your player and there are some interesting new ways of celebrating (moonwalk, anyone?) It would be nice to have the choice of group celebrations, but maybe that's something for FIFA11. Goalkeepers are also improved (or rather, are worse, but that's a good thing) in that they don't just bundle through you when 1 on 1 - meaning sometimes you can actually go round the keeper! Barmy, I know, but it is nice to be able to do something I took great delight in doing on the old PES games. Another nice idea is the fact smaller nations are so much harder to beat at home -evidenced when I drew 0-0 away to Andorra but then crushed them 7-0 at home with England. At Wembley it seemed pretty easy to carve them up and pass the ball around, but away they closed my players down much quicker and seemed to have a higher level of fitness.
Offline game modes are similar to FIFA10, but with the World Cup twist. So, you have kick off mode, the FIFA World Cup mode, Captain Your Country (where you can import your virtual pro from FIFA10 and make your way to the World Cup) and The Story of Qualifying, and excellent mode where you are given lots of scenarios take from World Cup qualifying to try (for example, getting Denmark to beat Portugal from 2-1 with 3 minutes to go). Each scenario has a break down of points to achieve (e.g. winning by two goals, not conceeding) and the more points you get, the closer you get to unlocking World Cup 2006 scenarios. Apparently during World Cup 2010 further scenarios will be added as the tournament plays out, which is a lovely idea. Another game mode is penalty shootout, which is ace as penalties have had a much-needed makeover. I won't go into details here as the explanation will be pretty lengthy, but it's definately worth trying this game to see how they handle penalties.
Online doesn't feature 10v10, but it does allow you to play the World Cup online, where you choose your team and stick with them as far as you can go in the tournament. There is also battle of the nations, where all the scores of everyone who plays a ranked game ae compiled according to their nation, and then when you sign in Clive Tyldsley helpfully lets you know that Holland are leading Mexico in the bid to be the best FIFA players.
So, there we have it. From a hardcore PES player back in the day, I can honestly say that, despite a few niggles (like in FIFA10), EA have created a wonderful game to accompany the upcoming World Cup. While certainly too big to be DLC, whether it has enough longevity in it to make you trade in FIFA10 is a tough one, as is whether it is worth a full-price retail price. That said, there's no doubt that the gameplay tweaks do help and the overall presentation is incredible. It's hard to fault the game itself, the AI can be a little bit wayward but like FIFA10 and the last-gen PES games, get a friend or two involved and it's fun, drama and last-minute screamers all the way. I'm hoping for a bigger step up when FIFA11 comes around, but for now this is more that sufficient.